For a balanced winter-tire choice, I’d start with the Dunlop Winter Maxx 2, while the Nokian Nordman 9 SUV is a standout for drivers who need a studded SUV tire. The NEXEN Winguard Winspike 3 is another option for icy routes where studs may suit local conditions. This lineup also includes studless tires for quieter everyday winter driving, studdable models for added flexibility, and several different sizes and set formats. The right pick depends on your vehicle’s required size, how often you face ice, and whether you prioritize road comfort or extra grip. Read on for the full breakdown and a guide to matching a tire to your winter roads.
Get business pricing on garage and car supplies
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 appears in two sizes, giving shoppers a familiar studless option to compare against the more specialized studded picks.
- The Nokian Nordman 9 SUV is the lineup’s SUV-specific studded option; it is a more focused choice than passenger-car touring tires.
- Accelera X Grip models make up much of the selection, but their sizes and set formats differ, so confirm whether a listing supplies two tires or four.
- Armstrong Ski-Trac models cover distinct needs: PC and S are studless options, while the HP listing adds an XL load designation and a different size.
- Studded, studdable, and studless are not interchangeable labels; local rules, road surfaces, and comfort priorities should shape the choice before brand or price.
| winter tire | Tire Size | Load Index | Tread Type | Load Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 Winter Ti | 205/60R16 | 96 | Asymmetrical | XL |
| Accelera X Grip 225/45R17 94V | 225/45R17 | 94 | Directional | — |
| Accelera X Grip 225/40R18 92V | 225/40R18 | 92 | Directional | — |
| Armstrong Ski-Trac PC 195/65R1 | 195/65R15 | 91 | Directional | SL |
| NEXEN Winguard Winspike 3 Wint | 195/65R15 | 95 | — | — |
| Accelera X Grip 235/45R18 98V | 235/45R18 | 98 | Directional | XL |
| Accelera X-Grip 205/55R16 91H | 205/55R16 | 91 | — | SL (Standard Load) |
| Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 Winter Ti | 215/55R17 | 94 | Asymmetrical | SL |
| Armstrong Ski-Trac HP 215/55R1 | 215/55R17 | 98 | Directional | XL |
| Armstrong Ski-Trac PC 205/55R1 | 205/55R16 | 91 | Directional | SL (Standard Load) |
| Nokian Nordman 9 SUV Studded W | 225/65R17 | 106 | Directional | — |
| Armstrong Ski-Trac S Winter To | 215/55R17 | 98 | Symmetrical | XL |
| Accelera X-Grip 205/55R16 91H | 205/55R16 | 91 | Directional | SL (Standard Load) |
| Accelera X Grip 225/45R17 94V | 225/45R17 | 94 | Directional | XL |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 Winter Tire, 205/60R16 96T XL
The Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 stands out for its balanced approach to winter driving, combining solid snow and slush traction with reliable stability. Its asymmetrical tread pattern and drainage grooves make it particularly effective at clearing water and slush, helping to reduce hydroplaning risks. Compared to the NEXEN Winguard Winspike 3, which emphasizes stud compatibility, the Dunlop offers a more versatile, studless solution that performs well across a range of winter conditions. The main tradeoff is that it’s designed specifically for winter use, so it might not deliver optimal performance in other seasons, and its limited reviews leave some questions about longevity. Still, for drivers seeking a dependable winter tire that handles severe conditions, this pick offers a well-rounded solution.
Pros:- Excellent traction on snow and slush due to specialized tread design
- Drainage grooves help prevent hydroplaning and improve water removal
- Severe weather certification ensures performance in harsh winter conditions
Cons:- Only suitable for winter; performance drops outside cold months
- Limited customer reviews provide less insight into long-term durability
Best for: Drivers who want a reliable, all-around winter tire that handles snow, slush, and cold conditions without the need for studs.
Not ideal for: Those who need a dedicated studded tire for icy roads or who plan to use their tires year-round and require more versatile performance.
- Tire Size:205/60R16
- Rim Size:16 inches
- Load Index:96
- Load Range:XL
- Tread Type:Asymmetrical
- Certification:Three Peak Mountain Snowflake
Our verdict“This tire is ideal for winter drivers who prioritize safety and stability in severe conditions without needing studs.”
Accelera X Grip 225/45R17 94V XL Studdable Winter Tires, Set of 2
The Accelera X Grip 225/45R17 excels in icy conditions thanks to its studdable design and winter-specific compound. Its directional tread pattern and grooves are optimized for snow and ice, offering enhanced grip when studs are added—making it a top choice for those who prioritize maximum traction on icy surfaces. Compared with the NEXEN Winguard Winspike 3, which offers optional studding and a focus on versatility, the Accelera is better suited for drivers who are willing to invest in studs for added grip. The main tradeoff is the need to purchase and install studs separately, which could be inconvenient or costly for some. Overall, this tire makes the most sense for winter drivers in icy climates willing to customize their grip for peak safety.
Pros:- Excellent ice traction with studding capability
- Directional tread and winter compound improve snow handling
- Grooves help disperse water and slush, reducing hydroplaning
Cons:- Studs are not included and must be bought separately
- Rims and wheels are not included, adding extra cost and effort
Best for: Drivers who frequently face icy conditions and are prepared to add studs for extra grip.
Not ideal for: Casual winter drivers or those seeking a simple, all-season solution—studs must be purchased separately and installed.
- Tire Size:225/45R17
- Rim Size:17 inches
- Load Index:94
- Load Capacity:1477 lbs per tire
- Tread Type:Directional
- Studdable:Yes
Our verdict“This tire is best suited for dedicated winter drivers who want maximum ice grip and are willing to install studs.”
Accelera X Grip 225/40R18 92V XL Studdable Winter Tires, Set of 2
The Accelera X Grip 225/40R18 is tailored for drivers seeking improved handling in winter conditions, thanks to its larger size and directional tread. While it shares many features with the 17-inch version, its broader footprint and reinforced sidewalls aim to enhance stability and steering response on icy and snowy roads. Compared with the 225/45R17 model, this tire offers slightly better handling due to its lower profile, but at the expense of ride comfort. Its ability to be studded makes it versatile for icy surfaces, although studs are sold separately. This tire makes sense for those who want a high-performance winter tire that doesn’t compromise handling at the expense of safety.
Pros:- Enhanced handling and stability thanks to larger size and reinforced sidewalls
- Studdable for improved ice grip when needed
- Grooves disperse slush and water effectively
Cons:- Studs are not included and must be purchased separately
- Lower profile may reduce ride comfort on rough winter roads
Best for: Performance-oriented drivers in winter climates who want to maintain sporty handling with optional studding.
Not ideal for: Drivers prioritizing comfort or those who dislike the idea of installing studs separately; it’s more performance-focused than plush.
- Tire Size:225/40R18
- Rim Size:18 inches
- Load Index:92
- Load Capacity:1389 lbs per tire
- Tread Type:Directional
- Studdable:Yes
Our verdict“This tire suits drivers who want winter safety combined with sporty handling, especially in icy conditions with optional studs.”
Armstrong Ski-Trac PC 195/65R15 91T Studless Winter Radial Tire
The Armstrong Ski-Trac PC is a notable choice for drivers who prefer a studless tire that still delivers solid winter traction. Its directional tread with 3D sipes enhances grip on icy and snowy surfaces by maximizing the contact patch during braking and cornering. Compared with the NEXEN Winguard Winspike 3, which offers optional studs and a more aggressive water evacuation design, the Ski-Trac emphasizes consistent performance without the need for additional hardware. Its main limitation is that, like most winter tires, it’s less effective outside cold months, and the relatively modest tread depth may wear faster in milder conditions. For those who seek reliable studless winter traction without the hassle of studs, this tire offers a balanced solution.
Pros:- Effective studless traction with 3D sipes and directional design
- Good water and slush evacuation due to circumferential grooves
- Easy to install and maintain without studs
Cons:- Less effective in mild or wet conditions outside winter
- Limited tread depth may impact longevity
Best for: Winter drivers who want a dependable, studless tire for icy and snowy roads without the complexity of stud installation.
Not ideal for: Drivers in consistently icy but also warm climates where a more aggressive tread or studded tire might be necessary.
- Tire Size:195/65R15
- Rim Size:15 inches
- Load Index:91
- Load Range:SL
- Tread Type:Directional
- Tread Depth:10/32 inches
Our verdict“This tire offers a solid studless option for winter driving in icy and snowy conditions, especially for those avoiding studs.”
NEXEN Winguard Winspike 3 Winter Tire, 195/65R15 95T
The NEXEN Winguard Winspike 3 is designed for drivers seeking a versatile winter tire with optional studding capabilities. Its deep, directional grooves efficiently channel water, slush, and snow, supporting both wet and icy conditions. Compared with the Accelera X Grip 225/45R17, which emphasizes maximum ice grip with added studs, the Winspike offers a balanced approach suitable for mixed winter conditions. Its 3PMSF certification confirms its performance in severe weather, while the inclusion of optional studs adds flexibility for icy roads. The main drawback is that studs are sold separately, and the warranty excludes road hazards, which may concern some buyers. This tire appeals to those who want a reliable, all-around winter tire that can be customized with studs.
Pros:- 3PMSF certification for severe winter conditions
- Optional studs for extra ice grip
- Deep grooves and dense siping improve water and slush evacuation
Cons:- Studs are sold separately, adding extra cost
- Warranty does not include road hazards
Best for: Winter drivers who need a capable, certified tire for snow, ice, and wet roads, with the option to add studs later.
Not ideal for: Those who want a fully studded tire included in the package or who prefer a tire with a longer manufacturer warranty covering road hazards.
- Tire Size:195/65R15
- Rim Size:15 inches
- Load Index:95
- Maximum Pressure:50 psi
- Tread Depth:11/32 inches
- Stud Compatibility:Optional TSMI #12 studs
Our verdict“This tire is well-suited for winter drivers who want a versatile, certified tire with optional studs for icy surfaces.”
Accelera X Grip 235/45R18 98V XL Studdable Winter Tires, Set of 4
I’d choose this Accelera X Grip for an 18-inch fitment when the option to add studs matters more than having a studless setup ready to go. Its directional tread and winter compound are intended to help with snow and ice, while the grooves channel water and slush away from the contact area. Unlike the Dunlop Winter Maxx 2, which is a studless, Three Peak Mountain Snowflake-certified option, this tire lets the owner decide whether to add studs for extra ice bite. That flexibility also means an extra step: studs are not listed as included, so the added grip is not there straight out of the box. The XL load range and 1,653-pound capacity per tire suit buyers who need that rating, but check vehicle fitment carefully. The package is four tires, not wheels.
Pros:- Studdable tread gives buyers the option of added ice grip.
- Directional tread and winter compound are designed for snow and ice traction.
- Grooves help move water and slush away from the tread.
- XL load range is rated for 1,653 pounds per tire.
Cons:- Studs are not listed as included, so added ice grip requires a separate step.
- Rims and wheels are not included.
- The 235/45R18 size limits fitment to vehicles specified for that tire size.
Best for: Drivers with a compatible 18-inch passenger vehicle or SUV who want a four-tire winter set and the option to add studs for icy routes.
Not ideal for: Drivers who want a ready-to-use studless tire, need wheels included, or have a vehicle that does not call for this size and XL load rating.
- Tire size:235/45R18
- Rim diameter:18 inches
- Load index:98
- Load capacity:1,653 lbs per tire
- Load range:XL
- Tread type:Directional
- Studdable:Yes
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- Package:4 tires; rims and wheels not included
Our verdict“Pick this four-tire set if your 18-inch vehicle calls for its fitment and you want the option to add studs rather than a studless design like the Dunlop Winter Maxx 2.”
Accelera X-Grip 205/55R16 91H Studdable Winter Touring Tire
This single 205/55R16 studdable tire is a practical fitment-focused pick for drivers who want winter touring tires with the option to add studs. Its standard-load rating and 1,356-pound capacity per tire distinguish it from the larger XL Accelera X Grip 235/45R18, which carries a higher load rating and targets a different wheel size. The X-Grip’s studdable construction gives buyers more choice for icy roads, but studs are not listed as included, so the tire does not provide that extra bite out of the box. Compared with the Armstrong Ski-Trac PC in the same 205/55R16 size, this Accelera offers stud flexibility, while the Armstrong is studless and lists directional tread, 3D sipes, and four circumferential grooves. This listing is for one tire only; plan accordingly when replacing a full set.
Pros:- Studdable design allows added ice traction if studs are installed.
- 205/55R16 sizing suits vehicles specified for this common fitment.
- Standard-load rating supports up to 1,356 pounds per tire.
- 10/32-inch listed tread depth provides a useful fitment reference.
Cons:- Sold as one tire, so a full set requires purchasing additional tires.
- Studs are not listed as included.
- The listing provides no warranty details.
Best for: Drivers with a vehicle specified for 205/55R16 tires who are replacing an individual tire or building a matched winter set and want stud options.
Not ideal for: Drivers seeking a complete four-tire package, included wheels, a studless design, or published warranty details.
- Tire size:205/55R16
- Rim diameter:16 inches
- Load index:91
- Load capacity:1,356 lbs per tire
- Load range:SL (Standard Load)
- Tread depth:10/32 inch
- Studdable:Yes
- Package:One tire; rim and wheel not included
Our verdict“Choose this single tire for a compatible 16-inch vehicle when stud flexibility matters, but opt for the studless Armstrong Ski-Trac PC if you prefer a documented tread design without studs.”
Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 Winter Tire, 215/55R17 94T
I’d put the Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 near the front of the list for drivers who want a studless winter tire with a clearly stated severe-snow certification. Its Three Peak Mountain Snowflake marking gives a concrete reference for winter capability, while the asymmetrical tread and wide drainage grooves are designed to support snow traction, turning stability, and water and slush evacuation. That makes it a more straightforward choice than the studdable Accelera X Grip 235/45R18 for buyers who do not want to make a separate decision about studs. The Armstrong Ski-Trac HP shares the 215/55R17 size and a winter focus, but it uses a directional tread and lists an XL load range; the Dunlop instead pairs its certification with an SL load range. Check the vehicle’s required load rating, and remember this is a seasonal tire, not a year-round solution.
Pros:- Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified for severe winter conditions.
- Wide drainage grooves are designed to clear water and slush.
- Asymmetrical tread is intended to support turning stability.
- Studless design avoids the need to choose or install studs.
Cons:- SL load range may not suit vehicles requiring an XL-rated tire.
- Winter-focused design is not intended as a year-round tire.
- The supplied product data does not specify whether it is sold individually or as a set.
Best for: Drivers with a vehicle specified for 215/55R17 tires who want a studless winter option with a Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certification.
Not ideal for: Drivers who need an XL load range, want studs for added ice bite, or need one tire for year-round use.
- Tire size:215/55R17
- Rim diameter:17 inches
- Load index:94
- Load range:SL
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Tread depth:11/32 inches
- Certification:Three Peak Mountain Snowflake
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
Our verdict“Choose the Dunlop if your 215/55R17 vehicle calls for its SL rating and you want certified studless winter traction rather than the stud option of the Accelera X Grip.”
Armstrong Ski-Trac HP 215/55R17 98V XL Studless Winter Radial Tire
The Ski-Trac HP is the 215/55R17 choice here for drivers whose vehicle needs an XL load range but who want a studless winter tire. Its 98 load index and listed 1,653-pound capacity per tire set it apart from the Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 in the same size, which has an SL load range and load index of 94. The Armstrong’s directional V-shaped tread channels water, while 3D shoulder sipes add biting edges intended to help on icy and snowy roads. Compared with the Accelera X Grip 235/45R18, the Ski-Trac HP does not offer a stud option; that suits buyers who prefer a studless setup, but not those seeking added grip from studs. It is sold as a tire only, and its winter-specific design means drivers will need another plan for warmer seasons.
Pros:- XL load range and 98 load index suit fitments requiring a higher load rating.
- Directional V-shaped tread is designed to channel water.
- 3D shoulder sipes provide additional biting edges for snow and ice.
- 50 psi maximum pressure is specified in the product data.
Cons:- Studless tread does not offer the option to add studs.
- Rims and wheels are not included.
- Winter-only use means it is not a year-round tire.
Best for: Drivers with a 215/55R17 fitment who need an XL load range and prefer a studless tire for winter driving.
Not ideal for: Drivers whose vehicle calls for an SL-rated tire, who want a studdable tread, or who need wheels included.
- Tire size:215/55R17
- Rim diameter:17 inches
- Load index:98
- Load capacity:1,653 lbs per tire
- Load range:XL
- Tread type:Directional
- Tread depth:10/32 inch
- Maximum pressure:50 psi
- Package:One tire; rim and wheel not included
Our verdict“Pick the Ski-Trac HP over the Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 when your 215/55R17 vehicle requires its XL load rating and you want a studless design.”
Armstrong Ski-Trac PC 205/55R16 91H SL Studless Winter Radial Tire
For a 205/55R16 passenger car, the Ski-Trac PC makes the strongest case when you want a studless touring tire with tread details aimed at mixed winter conditions. Its directional pattern, 3D sipes, and four circumferential grooves are designed to support grip and braking while moving water and slush away from the tread. Compared with the same-size Accelera X-Grip, the Armstrong gives up the option to add studs but spells out more of its tread features; that favors drivers who want a studless setup, not those who want adjustable ice traction. The Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 adds a Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certification, though it is a 17-inch tire and does not match this fitment. The PC has an SL load range and is sold as a tire only, so verify the vehicle’s required rating and plan for the rest of the set.
Pros:- Directional tread and 3D sipes are designed to aid winter grip and handling.
- Four circumferential grooves help evacuate water and slush.
- 20-pound listed weight is lower than the 23-pound Accelera X-Grip in the same size.
- Standard-load rating supports up to 1,356 pounds per tire.
Cons:- Studless construction does not allow added traction from studs.
- Sold as a tire only; wheels and a full set are not included.
- The supplied product data does not list a severe-snow certification.
Best for: Drivers of passenger cars specified for 205/55R16 tires who want a studless winter touring tire for snowy, icy, and slushy roads.
Not ideal for: Drivers seeking a studdable tire, a complete set, included wheels, or a tire with a Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certification listed in the supplied data.
- Tire size:205/55R16
- Rim diameter:16 inches
- Load index:91
- Load capacity:1,356 lbs per tire
- Load range:SL (Standard Load)
- Tread type:Directional
- Tread depth:10/32 inches
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- Tire diameter:24.9 inches
Our verdict“Choose the Ski-Trac PC if you want a studless 205/55R16 tire with specified grooves and sipes, and choose the Accelera X-Grip instead if stud flexibility matters more.”
Nokian Nordman 9 SUV Studded Winter Tire, 225/65R17 106T XL
For an SUV that regularly faces ice and deep snow, the Nordman 9 SUV is the most purpose-built choice in this group. Its embedded studs target grip on slick surfaces, while the directional winter tread is designed for snowy, slippery conditions. Compared with the studdable Accelera X-Grip tires, this Nokian arrives with studs rather than leaving that choice to the buyer. That focus comes with a constraint: studded tires may be restricted where you drive, and they are a specialized fit for winter use rather than a general year-round option. The listed 106 load index and XL designation suit an SUV fitment, but buyers should confirm the tire matches their vehicle requirements; the supplied load-capacity figure is inconsistent with the load index. It is sold as a tire only.
Pros:- Embedded studs are designed to add grip on icy surfaces.
- Directional tread is intended for deep snow and slippery conditions.
- 106 load index and XL designation are suited to a vehicle-specific SUV fitment.
- 13/32-inch tread depth and robust radial construction are aimed at winter use and wear resistance.
Cons:- Studded tires may be restricted in some locations.
- The supplied load-capacity figure conflicts with the 106 load index, so buyers should verify fitment data.
- Only the tire is included; wheels are not.
Best for: SUV drivers in areas with frequent icy roads and deep snow who can legally use studded tires and need the listed 225/65R17 fitment.
Not ideal for: Drivers in regions that restrict studs, or SUV owners whose vehicle requires a different tire size or load rating.
- Tire size:225/65R17
- Load index:106
- Tread type:Directional
- Construction:Radial
- Tread depth:13/32 inches
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tire diameter:28.5 inches
Our verdict“Choose this Nokian for a compatible SUV facing frequent ice and snow, provided studded tires are permitted where you drive.”
Armstrong Ski-Trac S Winter Touring Tires, 215/55R17, Set of 4
The Ski-Trac S stands out for buyers who need four matching winter tires in one purchase for a 215/55R17 passenger car or SUV. Its symmetrical tread is designed to support handling and stability, while the studdable design leaves open the option of adding studs where local conditions and rules call for them. Compared with the studded Nokian Nordman 9 SUV, the Armstrong does not arrive with studs, so it is less ready-made for persistent ice but offers more flexibility. The 98 load index, XL load range, and stated 1,653-pound capacity per tire provide useful fitment details to check against the vehicle placard. The tradeoff is that this is a tire-only set: wheels and rims are not included, and buyers still need appropriate installation and fitment confirmation.
Pros:- Set includes four tires for a full matching winter changeover.
- Studdable construction gives buyers the option of adding ice traction.
- Symmetrical tread is designed to support handling and stability.
- XL load range and listed load capacity provide fitment information for comparison with vehicle requirements.
Cons:- Studs are optional and not listed as included, so it is not ready-made for studded-tire use.
- Rims and wheels are not included.
- The 215/55R17 size will not fit vehicles requiring another tire size.
Best for: Drivers of compatible passenger cars or SUVs with 215/55R17 fitment who want a four-tire winter set and the option of adding studs.
Not ideal for: Drivers who need studs fitted from the outset for frequent ice, or anyone expecting wheels or rims to come with the set.
- Tire size:215/55R17
- Quantity:4 tires
- Load index:98
- Load range:XL
- Load capacity:1,653 pounds per tire
- Tread type:Symmetrical
- Tread depth:12/32 inches
- Studdable:Yes
Our verdict“Pick the Ski-Trac S if you need a four-tire 215/55R17 winter set with optional studding, not a pre-studded tire.”
Accelera X-Grip 205/55R16 91H SL Studdable Winter Tires, Set of 4
This X-Grip set is tailored to drivers whose cars call for 205/55R16 tires and who want four winter tires with the option to add studs. Its directional tread is designed to channel water and slush while supporting traction on snow and ice; the studdable construction adds another route to ice grip. Compared with the larger 225/45R17 Accelera X Grip set, this version is for a different wheel size and has a standard-load rating rather than XL. That makes vehicle fitment—not a broad performance claim—the reason to choose between them. A 91 load index and 1,356-pound capacity per tire should be checked against the car’s specifications. It is also a seasonal specialist: these winter tires may be less suited to warm-weather use, and the set includes tires only, not rims or wheels.
Pros:- Four tires are included for a complete seasonal changeover.
- Directional tread is designed for snow and ice traction and slush dispersal.
- Studdable design allows added ice grip where appropriate.
- Standard-load specification suits vehicles whose fitment calls for SL tires.
Cons:- Rims and wheels are not included.
- Winter-focused construction may be less suitable outside the cold season.
- Studs are not listed as included.
Best for: Compact-car owners whose vehicle specifies 205/55R16 and who want a four-tire winter set with optional studding.
Not ideal for: Drivers whose cars require another tire size or a higher load rating, and buyers seeking wheels or tires for year-round use.
- Tire size:205/55R16
- Quantity:4 tires
- Load index:91
- Load capacity:1,356 pounds per tire
- Load range:SL (Standard Load)
- Tread type:Directional
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- Studdable:Yes
Our verdict“Choose this set for a compatible 205/55R16 compact car when you want directional winter tread and the option to add studs.”
Accelera X Grip 225/45R17 94V XL Studdable Winter Tires, Set of 4
For a vehicle that specifies 225/45R17 and needs an XL load range, this four-tire X Grip set combines winter-focused directional tread with the option to add studs. Its grooves are designed to move water and slush, while the tread and winter compound target snow-and-ice traction. Compared with the 205/55R16 X-Grip set, this model uses a different fitment and carries an XL rating with a listed 1,477-pound capacity per tire; those distinctions matter more than the shared studdable design. The higher 94 load index does not make it a universal upgrade, so the vehicle’s required size and load rating should guide the choice. As with the other Accelera set, wheels are not included, and studs are an option rather than a stated part of the package.
Pros:- Set includes four tires for a complete winter changeover.
- XL load range and 94 load index suit compatible higher-load fitments.
- Directional tread and grooves are designed for snow, ice, and slush conditions.
- Studdable construction provides the option of added ice grip.
Cons:- Rims and wheels are not included.
- Studs are not listed as included.
- The 225/45R17 size and XL rating must match the vehicle’s required fitment.
Best for: Drivers whose vehicle specifies 225/45R17 XL tires and who want four winter tires with the option of adding studs.
Not ideal for: Owners whose fitment calls for a different tire size or standard-load tire, or drivers who need wheels included.
- Tire size:225/45R17
- Quantity:4 tires
- Load index:94
- Load capacity:1,477 pounds per tire
- Load range:XL
- Tread type:Directional
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- Studdable:Yes
Our verdict“Choose this X Grip set for a vehicle requiring 225/45R17 XL tires when you want winter tread and optional studding in a four-tire package.”
How We Picked
I organized the ranking around the decisions that matter most for winter driving: matching the tire to the vehicle, choosing a studded or studless design, and weighing everyday usability against a more specialized snow-and-ice setup. I also checked the listed sizes, load and speed markings, XL or SL designations, and whether each listing describes two tires or a set of four. Those details can affect compatibility and how much of a vehicle’s tire replacement a buyer still needs to arrange.
The order favors options with a clear role and broad usefulness, then places more specialized or less directly comparable listings lower. The Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 leads as a studless choice offered in two sizes; the Nokian Nordman 9 SUV ranks highly for a distinct SUV-and-studs use case. The Accelera and Armstrong listings provide useful alternatives, but their differing fitments, variants, and set formats make it especially important to compare the exact listing rather than choosing by model name alone. I did not infer test results or performance figures that are not provided in the product details.
| winter tire | Load Range | Tread Type |
|---|---|---|
| Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 Winter Ti | XL | Asymmetrical |
| Accelera X Grip 225/45R17 94V | — | Directional |
| Accelera X Grip 225/40R18 92V | — | Directional |
| Armstrong Ski-Trac PC 195/65R1 | SL | Directional |
| NEXEN Winguard Winspike 3 Wint | — | — |
| Accelera X Grip 235/45R18 98V | XL | Directional |
| Accelera X-Grip 205/55R16 91H | SL (Standard Load) | — |
| Dunlop Winter Maxx 2 Winter Ti | SL | Asymmetrical |
| Armstrong Ski-Trac HP 215/55R1 | XL | Directional |
| Armstrong Ski-Trac PC 205/55R1 | SL (Standard Load) | Directional |
| Nokian Nordman 9 SUV Studded W | — | Directional |
| Armstrong Ski-Trac S Winter To | XL | Symmetrical |
| Accelera X-Grip 205/55R16 91H | SL (Standard Load) | Directional |
| Accelera X Grip 225/45R17 94V | XL | Directional |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Winter Tires
Before choosing from this lineup, I’d narrow the field by vehicle fit, winter road conditions, and the kind of tire setup you can legally and practically use. These checks can prevent a seemingly suitable option from becoming a poor match once it is time to install the tires.
Start With the Vehicle’s Required Tire Size
Use the size listed on the vehicle’s door placard or in its owner’s manual as your starting point, rather than relying on the current tires alone. The options here span 195/65R15 through 235/45R18, so a model name by itself does not tell you whether a particular listing fits. Keep the full size string intact, including load and speed markings, and check any vehicle-specific requirements. A tire that is close in width or diameter is not automatically an acceptable substitute. If you are considering a different size, get confirmation from a qualified tire professional before ordering.
Choose Studded, Studdable, or Studless for Your Roads
Studded tires have studs fitted, studdable models are designed to accept studs, and studless tires rely on their tread and compound rather than metal studs. These approaches suit different driving conditions, and a studdable label does not mean the tire arrives with studs installed. Studs may help on certain icy roads, but their use can be restricted by location or season, so check local rules before buying. Drivers who regularly encounter mixed winter roads may prefer a studless option instead of choosing studs for occasional ice. Decide based on the roads you actually travel, not only on the harshest conditions you might face.
Check Load and Speed Markings, Not Just Tire Size
Load and speed markings are part of the fitment information, not decorative details. Listings in this roundup include different ratings and XL or SL designations, which can affect whether a tire meets the vehicle maker’s requirements. Do not assume that a higher-looking number makes a tire a better choice if it does not match the vehicle’s specifications. Compare every marking with the placard or manual, especially when moving between standard-load and XL options. If the markings do not line up, ask a tire professional to verify the fit before purchase.
Confirm How Many Tires the Listing Includes
Some listings here specify a set of two, others a set of four, and several name a single tire. That distinction changes what you need to order and whether the tires can be replaced as a matched set. Winter tires are generally fitted in matching pairs at a minimum, while replacing all four helps maintain consistent handling between the front and rear axles. Do not assume that the same model in another size or listing has the same package quantity. Check the item title and seller details for both quantity and fitment before completing an order.
Match the Tire to Your Vehicle Type and Daily Use
A passenger-car touring tire and an SUV-specific tire are not interchangeable just because a size appears close. The Nordman 9 SUV listing is explicitly aimed at SUV fitments, while most of the other options are presented as passenger-car or touring tires. Think about how you use the vehicle in winter: regular commuting, steep local roads, or occasional trips on untreated routes can lead to different priorities. For frequent highway driving, everyday comfort and a suitable fit may matter more than selecting the most specialized snow setup. Check the tire’s stated application and vehicle requirements rather than assuming one winter model suits every vehicle.
Pay for the Feature You Will Actually Use
A specialized studded tire makes more sense when icy conditions are a regular part of your driving and local rules allow it; it may be an unnecessary compromise for mostly clear urban roads. A studless tire can better suit drivers who want one winter setup for varied everyday conditions. The listings also vary in size and package quantity, so compare the complete replacement needs rather than judging a model from its name alone. Do not pay extra for an XL designation or a specialized vehicle fit unless your vehicle and use case call for it. When two options both fit, prioritize the design that matches your most common winter roads.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I buy just two winter tires instead of four?
It depends on the vehicle, its drivetrain, and the condition of the tires already fitted, but mixing winter and non-winter tires can change handling balance. In general, a matching set of four gives more consistent grip between axles. If replacing only two is unavoidable, ask a tire professional which axle should receive them for your vehicle and follow the manufacturer’s guidance. This roundup includes listings for two tires and four, so verify package quantity before ordering. Do not assume a “set of two” listing will cover a full vehicle.
Should I choose a studdable tire if I might need studs later?
A studdable tire can offer flexibility, but it does not necessarily include studs or mean you can add them at any time. Check the listing and ask the installer whether stud installation is supported and when it needs to be done. You should also confirm that studs are permitted where and when you drive. If icy roads are rare and most trips are on cleared streets, a studless tire may be the simpler fit. Choose studdable construction for a real use case, not just as a precaution.
Can I use an SUV winter tire on a passenger car if the size matches?
A matching size alone is not enough to confirm suitability. The vehicle’s required load and speed ratings, tire construction, and manufacturer fitment guidance all matter. The Nordman 9 SUV in this roundup is identified for SUV use, so I would not treat it as a general substitute for a passenger-car tire. Compare the full tire markings against your vehicle placard and consult a qualified tire professional if anything differs. A correct fit should satisfy the vehicle’s requirements, not just clear the wheel well.
Do I need to replace my summer tires with winter tires on all four wheels?
For most drivers using a dedicated winter setup, fitting matching winter tires on all four wheels helps keep traction and handling more balanced. Putting winter tires on only one axle can create different grip levels between the front and rear, which may affect control. The right plan still depends on the vehicle maker’s instructions and the condition of the existing tires. If you are considering a two-tire listing, ask an installer whether it is appropriate for your situation before buying. Check package quantity carefully so the order matches the plan.
How do I choose between two winter tires in the same size?
First confirm that both match your vehicle’s complete size, load, and speed requirements. Then compare their design: studded, studdable, or studless, and whether the tire is specified for a passenger car or SUV. Think about your regular routes and local stud rules rather than choosing based on an occasional trip in unusual weather. Finally, check whether each listing includes one tire, two, or four, since package contents can change the overall purchase you need to make. If those details still leave two suitable choices, ask an installer to verify the fit for your vehicle.
Conclusion
For the best overall balance in this lineup, I’d begin with the Dunlop Winter Maxx 2, while confirming the correct size and vehicle fit. The Accelera X Grip listings are a practical place to compare for buyers prioritizing a studdable option, but check the exact size and whether the listing includes two or four tires; I would not name one listing the best value without verified price and performance data. For a premium, specialized SUV need, the Nokian Nordman 9 SUV is the clearest fit for shoppers seeking a studded SUV tire. Beginners may find a studless option easier to choose if they do not need studs, while drivers facing frequent ice should check local regulations and compare the studded NEXEN or SUV-specific Nokian to their needs. The best choice is the one that matches your vehicle’s full specifications and the winter roads you drive most often.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
